Blog

Understanding the Difference Between Child Themes and Custom Themes in WordPress

One of the common points of confusion I still encounter is the difference between using a child theme and simply copying a WordPress theme to create a custom theme. While both approaches have their place, they serve different purposes and have distinct pros and cons.

In this article, I will dive deep into the technical and strategic differences between these two approaches. We’ll cover:

  • What is a WordPress Child Theme?
  • When to Use a Child Theme
  • What is a Custom (Cloned) Theme?
  • When to Use a Custom Theme
  • Pros and Cons of Each
  • Code Examples
  • Best Practices
  • Tools and Resources

What is a WordPress Child Theme?

A child theme is a theme that inherits the functionality and styling of another theme, called the parent theme. It allows you to make changes and customizations without modifying the parent theme directly.

WordPress loads the child theme first and then falls back to the parent theme when necessary. This makes child themes a powerful and safe way to modify existing themes.

Directory Structure

Here’s what a basic child theme might look like:

wp-content/
└── themes/
    ├── parent-theme/
    └── my-child-theme/
        ├── style.css
        ├── functions.php
        └── (optional templates)

style.css (required)

/*
 Theme Name:   My Child Theme
 Template:     parent-theme
*/

functions.php (optional but commonly used)

<?php
function my_child_theme_enqueue_styles() {
    wp_enqueue_style('parent-style', get_template_directory_uri() . '/style.css');
    wp_enqueue_style('child-style', get_stylesheet_directory_uri() . '/style.css', array('parent-style'));
}
add_action('wp_enqueue_scripts', 'my_child_theme_enqueue_styles');

By enqueuing the parent theme’s stylesheet and optionally adding your own CSS or template overrides, you can fully customize the theme behavior.

Use Cases for Child Themes

  • You want to make small to medium customizations to an existing theme.
  • You want to ensure updates to the parent theme won’t overwrite your changes.
  • You’re using a framework like Genesis, Astra, or Hello Elementor that encourages child themes.

What is a Custom (Cloned) Theme?

A custom theme built by cloning an existing one involves copying the entire theme folder and then editing the copied version. This cloned version becomes a fully standalone theme.

Directory Structure

wp-content/
└── themes/
    └── my-custom-theme/
        ├── style.css
        ├── functions.php
        ├── header.php
        ├── footer.php
        └── ...all other theme files

This approach is more akin to traditional development where you own the whole codebase.

style.css (for cloned theme)

/*
 Theme Name: My Custom Theme
*/

functions.php (example customization)

<?php
// Custom function
function my_custom_theme_setup() {
    add_theme_support('post-thumbnails');
    register_nav_menus(array(
        'primary' => __('Primary Menu')
    ));
}
add_action('after_setup_theme', 'my_custom_theme_setup');

Use Cases for Custom Themes

  • You want full control over design and functionality.
  • You’re building a highly specific site where an existing theme is too limiting.
  • You need to eliminate bloat from a theme that includes features you don’t need.

Pros and Cons

Child Themes

Pros:

  • Safe from theme updates.
  • Fast to set up and maintain.
  • Great for leveraging mature themes or frameworks.

Cons:

  • Dependent on parent theme structure.
  • Limited flexibility for deep customization.
  • Potential issues if the parent theme is deprecated or changes dramatically.

Custom Themes

Pros:

  • Complete control over every aspect of the site.
  • No dependency on an external codebase.
  • Easier to optimize for performance.

Cons:

  • Requires more time and development expertise.
  • You have to handle all updates and bug fixes.
  • Can be overkill for simple websites.

Real-World Scenarios

Scenario 1: Using a Child Theme

Let’s say you’re building a blog for a client using the Astra theme, which they like for its lightweight design and WooCommerce support. You want to customize the footer and change a few styles.

You would create a child theme and override footer.php or add custom CSS to style.css.

Scenario 2: Creating a Custom Theme

You’re building a membership website for a niche market with a very specific UI and custom workflows. Rather than strip down an existing theme, it makes more sense to start from scratch or use something minimal like _s (Underscores) as your base.

Best Practices

For Child Themes:

  • Only override what you need.
  • Use hooks and filters when possible instead of overriding whole files.
  • Keep your customizations modular and well-commented.

For Custom Themes:

  • Start with a bare-bones starter like Underscores (_s).
  • Use version control (e.g., Git) from day one.
  • Structure your theme logically: /inc, /templates, /assets, etc.
  • Build with performance and accessibility in mind.

Helpful Tools

Conclusion

The choice between using a child theme and building a custom theme from scratch comes down to project requirements, time constraints, and long-term maintainability.

  • Use a child theme when you can leverage an existing theme that does 80-90% of what you need.
  • Build a custom theme when you require full control or when your design deviates significantly from anything off-the-shelf.

Both approaches are valid and have stood the test of time in the WordPress ecosystem. As always, plan ahead, document your work, and think about who will maintain the site after you.

Happy theming!

Tags: , , ,

Leave a Reply